You’re reviewing a PMS factsheet and come across a table filled with numbers and performance metrics.
Most of us look at one number first: the return. But the return only tells you where you ended up. It does not tell you what the journey cost.
We have already explained return metrics like XIRR, TWRR and CAGR in an earlier blog. You can read it here.
In this blog, we focus only on risk.
Return is what you earned. Risk is what you went through to earn it.
Key Risk Metrics, Explained
Metric 1
Alpha
Alpha measures the excess return generated by the portfolio after adjusting for the risk taken compared with its benchmark. Unlike simply comparing portfolio returns with benchmark returns, Alpha also considers the portfolio’s Beta and the risk-free return.
- For example, if a PMS generates 10%, the benchmark generates 7%, the risk-free return is 4%, and Beta is 0.75:
Example
- So, although the portfolio outperformed the benchmark by only 3%, its risk-adjusted Alpha is 3.75% because it generated that return with lower volatility than the benchmark.
How to read it
A positive Alpha means the manager added value beyond what the market and the risk level would explain. Look at it over several years, not just one.Standard Deviation
Standard Deviation measures the overall volatility or risk of a portfolio. A higher SD means the portfolio’s returns fluctuate more and therefore carry higher volatility.
- Suppose PMS A has an SD of 15%, while PMS B has an SD of 25%. PMS B is more volatile, meaning its returns can fluctuate more significantly than PMS A.
Example
If you invest ₹1 lakh — PMS A (15% SD): ₹15,000 range of volatility. PMS B (25% SD): ₹25,000 range of volatility.
- So, higher SD = higher volatility, while lower SD indicates relatively more stable returns.
How to read it
Lower means a steadier ride. Higher means a bumpier one. Neither is automatically good or bad. It must be read alongside the return earned.Metric 3
Beta
A measure of sensitivity to the benchmark. For PMS reports, this is usually the BSE 500 TRI.
- Beta < 1: Portfolio is less volatile than the benchmark.
Example
Beta of 0.8 → tends to fall about 8% when the market falls 10%.
- Beta = 1: Portfolio has similar volatility to the benchmark.
Example
Beta of 1.0 → moves roughly in line with the market.
- Beta > 1: Portfolio is more volatile than the benchmark.
Example
Beta of 1.2 → tends to fall about 12% when the market falls 10%.
How to read it
Beta tells you how much market risk you are carrying. A higher Beta can mean higher gains in good times and bigger falls in bad times.Sharpe Ratio
Sharpe Ratio measures how much excess return a PMS generates for every unit of risk taken. It considers the portfolio’s return, the risk-free rate, and its Standard Deviation.
- Beta < 1: Portfolio is less volatile than the benchmark.
Example
Assume the risk-free rate is 6%.
- PMS A: 14% return with 28% risk. Sharpe = (14 − 6) ÷ 28 = 0.29
- PMS B: 16% return with 18% risk. Sharpe = (16 − 6) ÷ 18 = 0.56
PMS B earned a higher return and took less risk to do it. That makes it more efficient on a risk-adjusted basis.
How to read it
Higher Sharpe Ratio means better risk-adjusted performance. Always compare it across the same period and a similar strategy.
Metrics 5 & 6
Capture Ratio
Capture Ratios compare the fund return with its benchmark during good months and bad months separately. A fund’s relationship with the market is not always one-to-one. It can gain more than the market when things go well, and lose less when things go badly. Capture ratios measure that.
Participation in gains
Average fund return in months the benchmark was positive, divided by the benchmark’s average return in those same months.
Participation in losses
Average fund return in months the benchmark was negative, divided by the benchmark’s average return in those same months.
How to read it
Always read upside and downside capture together. A low upside does not automatically mean a weak fund, and a high upside does not automatically mean a strong one. Look for higher upside capture than downside capture, over a long period, against the same benchmark.
Metric 7
Portfolio Turnover Ratio
One last number how much the portfolio actually moved during the year.
Portfolio Turnover Ratio (PTR)
Measures how much of a fund’s portfolio has been bought or sold during a year it tells investors how actively the fund manager is trading, versus how much they’re letting existing holdings sit and compound.
Formula
PTR = ( Total Value of Purchases or Sales, whichever is higher ÷ Average Net Assets Under Management ) × 100
How to read it
A higher PTR means more trading. A lower PTR means more patience. Neither is right or wrong. What matters is whether the activity fits the strategy and whether the results justify it.
Conclusion
No single number tells the full story. Read them together, against the same benchmark, over a long period.
The next time your PMS report arrives, don’t stop at the return. Check how bumpy the ride was, how the portfolio behaved when the market fell, and whether the risk taken was worth the result.
A good report is not the one with the biggest number. It is the one you understand.
At Turtle Wealth, we believe in Data Over Emotion. Discipline Over Bias. Alpha Through Process. Understanding your report is where that begins. If any number in yours is unclear, ask us. We are happy to walk you through it.
Regards,
Kirti Golicha – Research Analyst
DISCLAIMERS:
Turtle Wealth Management Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “the Company”) is a SEBI registered Portfolio Manager, SEBI Reg. No: INP000006758. Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks, and there is no assurance or guarantee that the objectives of any investment portfolio will be achieved. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Above performance data is not verified by SEBI.

